Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label Nietzsche. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nietzsche. Show all posts

Monday, 6 December 2010

HCJ Seminar: John Carey

John Carey was born 5 April 1934 and is a British literary critic, and emeritus Merton Proffesor of English Literature at the University of Oxford . He was born in Barnes, London, and educated at Richmond and East Sheen Boys’ Grammar School, winning an Open Scholarship to St Johns College, Oxford. He served in the East Surrey Regiment, 1952-1954, and was commissioned. After posts in a number of Oxford colleges, he became Merton Professor in 1975, retiring in 2001.

He has twice chaired the Booker Prize
committee, in 1982 and 2004, and chaired the judging panel for the first Man Booker International Prize in 2005. He is chief book reviewer for the London Sunday Times and appears in radio and TV programmes such as Saturday Review and Newsnight Review.

The sub-title of his book, Intellectuals among the masses is: Pride and Prejudice among the Literary Intelligentsia, 1880-1939.The book comes in two parts. The first part contains various ‘themes’ and the second offers case studies of several writers.It seems that Carey doesn’t have much time for the literary intelligentsia and comes across that he despises large numbers of them.

The general thesis of the book is that the (largely self-anointed) intellectual classes were deeply shaken by nineteenth-century social developments. Although Carey doesnt mention the French Revolution of 1789 it is possible that the event was deeply disturbing to all those in Europe who held positions of influence, power, and wealth.

What the French Revolution demonstrated was that you weren’t necessarily safe even if you were a King. You could still end up in prison, or with your head chopped off.As the nineteenth century moved on, the ruling classes (from whom intellectuals were exclusively drawn in those days) began to be aware that the masses were rapidly growing in power and influence and also being taught to read! This led to a widespread and deep-seated fear of the masses through the intelligentsia.

As far as literature is concerned, Carey argues that, in the face of this much enlarged reading public, the response of the intellectuals was to create new forms of work which were deliberately exclusive. The whole point (conscious or unconscious) of modernist literature was to exclude the ordinary people. It was to create a class of writers and readers who could feel comfortably superior to the masses, because only they – the new intelligentsia – were clever enough to understand the new literature, and to be aware that there were still people like themselves – people who were so infinitely superior, in every way, to the great unwashed masses who revelled in sordid crime stories and slushy romances.

Ortega y Gasset, for example, in The Dehumanization of Art, argued that it was the essential function of modern art to divide the public into two classes – those who can understand it and those who cannot. The intellectuals could not prevent the masses from learning to read. But they could prevent them reading certain types of literature by making it too difficult; and this they did.

Carey reveals that intellectuals such as Nietzsche and Ortega y Gasset were quite nasty people. ‘I believe,’ said Nietzsche, ‘that the mob, the mass, the herd, will always be despicable.’ The immense popularity of Nietzsche’s ideas, Carey tells us, is indicative of the sheer panic that the threat of the masses induced.F.R. Leavis declared that the mass media arouse ‘the cheapest emotional responses. Films, newspapers, publicity in all forms, commercially-catered fiction – all offer satisfaction at the lowest level.’The fear of the masses also acted as the cover for an equally nasty attitude among the intelligentsia, and that was the fear of women. Popular newspapers were hated and despised because they encouraged women to better themselves. A whole array of intellectuals are revealed by Carey not merely to be snobs and fuzzy thinkers, but possessed of singularly unattractive opinions based on nothing more than prejudice, stupidity and fear for their life style.

Carey shocks the readers when he relates that some of the intelligentsia in the early twentieth century anticipated Hitler in favouring the extermination of the old, the sick, and the suffering. Lawrence was among them. ‘If I had my way,’ he said in a letter of 1908, ‘I would build a lethal chamber as big as the Crystal Palace.’

The literary intelligentsia created a class of literature which was impossible for the average reader to understand. But it probably didnt provide much pleasure for the elite, except that it allowed them to demonstrate, to their own satisfaction at least, that they were infinitely superior in every way to the masses. That is the price you have to pay for being allowed to feel superior; you don’t actually enjoy anything very much.All these attitudes were reflected in the book.

The principal aim of all this, says Carey, was ‘to acquire the control over the mass that language gives.’ After all, if the masses exercised power, they would probably start spreading out wealth more equally. Democratic government, thought Thomas Hardy, would lead to ‘the utter ruin of art and literature.’The masses were feared because it was thought that they would behave like crowds: i.e. they would be ‘extremely suggestible, impulsive, irrational, exaggeratedly emotional, inconstant, irritable and capable only of thinking in images – in short, just like women.’ The process of civilising women was considered by the intellectuals to be one of extreme difficulty.

Every development which favoured the middle or working classes in England was viewed with deep suspicion if not outright hostility. Suburban growth, with improved new housing, was decried for ruining the countryside. Cyril Connolly considered suburbs worse than slums.Carey shows that in the period covered by his book, 1880-1939, English intellectuals (in particular) were an unpleasant, snobbish group. Terrified that they might lose all their privileges, they objected on the one hand to anything which might be called progress, while on the other hand they busily reinforced their own all too fallible self esteem through the creation of ‘superior art’ which the masses could not understand.The trend continues to this day.

After the general introduction of part one, part two of Carey’s book provides several case studies. He deals with George Gissing, H.G. Wells, Arnold Bennett, and Wyndham Lewis, particularly the latter’s connection with Hitler.Gissing, though now forgotten, ‘was the earliest English writer to formulate the intellectuals’ case against mass culture, and he formulated it so thoroughly that nothing essential has been added to it since.’ Gissing, incidentally, was a charming fellow whose sexual appetites required women who were his intellectual and social inferior, and he could only get it up by humiliating and punishing them. He claimed to have beaten both his wives with stair rods.

H.G. Wells views are also unattractive from our perspective. What will we do with the black and the brown races, he wondered, since they are so obviously inferior to us in intelligence and initiative, and there are so many of them. He became obsessed with reducing the world’s population.

Arnold Bennett is included by Carey because the author views him as a hero. ‘His writings represent a systematic dismemberment of the intellectuals’ case against the masses.’ But Bennett was despised by the intelligentsia because he made money from literature. Intellectuals, Bennett believed he should write to appeal to a wider audience, and he did not see why a book which the masses liked should automatically be thought of as trash. Between the popular and the highbrow reader there was, he argued, no essential difference. Neither is there: in fiction both seek emotion; in non-fiction both seek information.

Wyndham Lewis wrote several books in the 1930s, all of which were enthusiastic about the German Fuhrer. Contempt for women was perhaps the key to Lewis’s character. ‘Stay to dinner,’ he asked a friend. ‘I’ve a wife downstairs. A simple woman, but a good cook.’Wyndham Lewis suggested that Whiteness ‘is in a pigmentary sense aristocratic’, and is the proper colour for a gentleman. As far as Hitler himself is concerned, Carey tells us that ‘the tragedy of Mein Kampf is that it was not, in many respects, a deviant work but one firmly rooted in European intellectual orthodoxy.’

Carey ends his survey at 1939, but he reminds us that the old intellectual prejudices have not died out yet. The ever-expanding mass media have ‘driven the intellectuals to evolve an anti-popular cultural mode that can reprocess all existing culture and take it out of the reach of the majority.’ This mode is variously called ‘post-structuralism’, or ‘deconstruction’, or just plain ‘theory’, and it began in the 1960s with the work of Jacques Derrida. It has managed, says Carey, to evolve a language that is impenetrable to most native English-speakers.

Carey has summed up all the modern apparatus of criticism and reviewing very neatly. Every department of Literature in every university and college in the world takes the line that there is a form of ‘serious literary fiction’ which is inherently superior to popular or commercial fiction. But there are no sound arguments or research data which demonstrate this. There is no evidence for seeing the world of fiction as a hierarchy.

Much of Carey's vitriol has been deployed, over the years, against snobbery and intellectual pretension. His championing of conventional values against those of the intellectual and social elite, a recurrent theme of his journalism in the 70s and 80s, found its fullest expression in his book The Intellectuals and the Masses (1992).

When it was published, The Intellectuals and the Masses was criticised for going too far in eliding British intellectuals' snobberies with fascist ideology, as if modernism taken to its logical conclusion would automatically lead to Nazism.. The idea that some people should be regarded as more valuable than others - or that culture should be divided into high and low, or society into upper and lower classes - clearly causes Carey almost physical pain. "I think the distribution of wealth is disgusting," he says. On the one hand, he passionately believes in the moral equality of all, and thinks everyone should have a chance to prove themselves regardless of background. But perhaps, at some level, his onslaught against elitism also reflects an irrational guilt about the fact that he and his successful sisters - one became a headmistress, the other a senior manager at Barclays - were born with greater life-chances than their brother.

Sources
John Carey: The Intellectuals and the Masses
http://www.wikipedia.com/
http://www.grumpyoldbookman.blogspot.com/
www.guardian.co.uk/books/2005/jun/.../art.oxforduniversity
www.faber.co.uk/work/intellectuals-and-masses/978057/1169269/

Thursday, 4 November 2010

Seminar Paper: Thus Spoke Zarathustra

Friedrich Nietzsche was born in 1844 in Rocken, Germany, and was the son of a minister. When Nietzche was quite young, his father went insane and died, leaving him to grow up in a household of women. He went on to become an excellent student, and was granted a doctorate in philology (study of language in written historical sources) at the age of 24, before he had even written a dissertation. At this time, he was a follower of Immanuel Kant, although he criticized him later on in his life.

In 1870, Nietzsche served as a medical orderly in the Franco-Prussian War, where he contracted dysentery, diphtheria, and possibly syphilis. He suffered from increasing ill health, migraines, indigestion, insomnia, and near blindness for the rest of his life.
Thus Spoke Zarathustra was published in four parts between 1883 and 1885. Nietzsche wrote each of the first three parts in ten-day periods and each part was published separately, with the fourth part not reaching the general public until 1892.
In January 1889 he collapsed in the street and soon after became insane, like his father. He remained in an incapacitated state for the last eleven years of his life, and died in 1900, aged 56.
Nietzsche has influenced twentieth-century philosophy more than almost any other thinker has. He has been an inspiration to almost every new movement in European philosophy in this century, and his critiques and methodology were far ahead of his time.

Thus Spoke Zarathustra, as the title implies, revolves around Zarathustra, who was a Persian prophet who lived and preached in the fifth century. He was the first philosopher to believe in a universe that is fundamentally defined by a struggle between good and evil. Nietzsche uses him as his protagonist, since, he believed, the first prophet to preach about good and evil should also be the first to move beyond good and evil. In the book, Zarathustra preaches about the overman who has moved beyond the concepts of good and evil, and has embraced the eternal recurrence. It is unclear whether or not Nietzsche means Zarathustra himself to be an overman, though if this is the case, this only occurs in the fourth part of the book, when he finally embraces the eternal recurrence.

The Overman is the goal of humanity. It is someone who has overcome himself fully: he obeys no laws except the ones he gives himself. This means a level of self- mastery that frees him from the prejudices and assumptions of the people around him. The Overman has a creative will, and a strong will to power. Zarathustra suggests that no overman has yet existed, but that we must try to breed one. As a race, we are only justified by the exceptional people among us.

The term “Eternal Recurrence” is the idea that all events will be repeated over and over again for all eternity. Zarathustra outlines his vision of the eternal recurrence in Part III: If the past stretches back infinitely, then anything that could have happened must have happened already at some time in the past. Meaning every moment has already occurred in the past and must recur again sometime in the future. Walter Kaufmann reads this as a scientific hypothesis that is mistaken. Gilles Deleuze reads this as a fundamental expression of the fact that the universe is in a constant state of change and becoming, and that there is no moment of fixity, or being. Nietzsche would probably agree with Deleuze. The overman can look at his past and himself as something entirely willed by himself, and be delighted by the thought that this process (which includes changes) will recur forever.

The novel opens with Zarathustra descending from his cave in the mountains after ten years of solitude. He is full of wisdom and love, and wants to teach humanity about the overman. He arrives in the town of Motley Cow, and announces that the overman must be the meaning of the earth. Mankind is just a bridge between animal and overman, and as such, must be overcome. The overman is someone who is free from all the prejudices and moralities of human society, and who creates his own values and purpose.

There are three stages of progress toward the overman: the camel, the lion, and the child. In the first, one must renounce their comforts, exercise self- discipline, and accept all sorts of difficulties for the sake of knowledge and strength. Second, one must assert their independence, saying "no" to all outside influences and commands, and lastly comes the act of new creation.
The bulk of the first three parts is made up of individual lessons and sermons delivered by Zarathustra. They cover most of the general themes of Nietzsche's mature philosophy, though often in highly symbolic and ambiguous form. He values struggle and hardship, since the road toward the overman is difficult and requires a great deal of sacrifice. The struggle toward the overman is often symbolically represented as climbing a mountain, and the light-hearted free spirit of the overman is often represented through laughter and dance.

Zarathustra is harshly critical of all kinds of mass movements, and of the "rabble" in general. Christianity is based upon a hatred of the body and of this earth, and an attempt to deny them both by believing in the spirit and in an afterlife. Nationalism and mass politics are also means by which weary, weak, or sick bodies try to escape from themselves. Zarathustra suggests that those who are strong enough, struggle. Those who are not strong give up and turn to religion, nationalism, democracy, or some other means of escape.

The conclusion of Zarathustra's preaching is the principle of the eternal recurrence, which claims that all events will repeat themselves again and again forever. Only the overman can embrace this doctrine, since only the overman has the strength of will to take responsibility for every moment in his life and to wish nothing more than for each moment to be repeated. Zarathustra has trouble facing the eternal recurrence, as he cannot bear the thought that the mediocrity of society will be repeated through all eternity without improvement.
In Part IV, Zarathustra assembles a number of men in his cave who he feels are as close possible to becoming the overman. There, they enjoy a feast and a number of songs. The book ends with Zarathustra joyfully embracing the eternal recurrence, and the thought that "all joy wants deep eternity."

Thus Spoke Zarathustra is one of the strangest books in the Western philosophical tradition because it is written in a similar style to the Gospels in the Bible and is full of biblical allusions, but it also harshly condemns Christianity and mocks the idea of a holy scripture or a holy person. Zarathustra is essentially a man who praises laughter, and who is even able to laugh at himself.
Nietzsche's subtitle—"A Book for None and All"— explains the peculiar style in which it was written. Nietzsche was an incredibly lonely man, and he believed that none of his peers understood him intellectually. He knew perfectly well that his works would be misunderstood, and his writings are full with harsh condemnations of "the rabble." In that sense, Zarathustra is a book for none: Nietzsche feared that his writings would fall on deaf ears. On the other hand, his subject matter concerns the fate and destiny of the human race, and in that sense it is a book for all. The fact that Nietzsche felt his work to be of supreme significance along with the fact that he had no sense of an audience explains the boldness of his writing.

Nietzsche's philosophy, and Zarathustra in particular, can be explained using the principle of the will to power as the fundamental force of all things. Everything must obey something, and if one can't obey themselves, they must obey someone else. True freedom is only granted to those who can command themselves. The will to power does not apply only to beings, but also to ideas: religion, morality, truth, and other concepts are all subject to the same struggle for power that dominates life. Because all things are characterized by a constant struggling, striving, and overcoming, nothing can remain fixed in place for too long. All things are constantly changing; permanence and stability are mere illusions.

Examples of this are Christianity's belief in absolutes or in God, the rabble's love of nationalism and democracy, and the scholar's obsession with truth. They can all be condemned as contrary to the spirit of change, impermanence, and inequality that are essential to life. Those who strive against this spirit of change are striving against life, and thus are clearly sick and weak and wanting to escape from life.
The overman, however, is the full realization of a healthy will to power. He has gained complete power over himself, so that he is entirely a creation of his own will. His character, his values, his spirit are all exactly as he has willed them to be. In that sense, the overman is totally free and absolutely powerful.

Sources
Thus Spoke Zarathustra-Friedrich Nietzche
http://www.google.com/http://www.wikipedia.com/
http://www.sparknotes.com/
http://www.wsu.edu/~brians/hum_303/zarathustra.html